MONTHLY LONG-FORM ARTICLE: the patients who do not need more testing - what thirty years has taught me about when more data stops helping.

I run a practice that believes in data. We use body composition scans, mobility and strength assessments, and lab work. I was the first person through our own lab work. I'll defend objective measurement to anyone who asks.

So this may sound strange coming from me: some of the people who walk through our door do not need another test. They need another person.

Decades in this work has taught me to recognize them. I suspect you can, too.

The folder

You know the folder. Sometimes it's a binder. Lately it's a phone full of screenshots.

It holds a lipid panel from last spring, a different panel from a different practice in the fall, a sleep score history, a glucose monitor export, and a printout of a conversation with an AI chatbot about all of the above.

The person holding it is smart, motivated, and tired. They have done the responsible thing over and over. And they come to us asking which test they should get next.

Very often, the honest answer is none. Not yet.

The question underneath

Data earns its place in our work when it sets a baseline, changes a decision, or tells us whether a plan is working. Underneath all three is a question you ask in your own practice every day: will this result change what we do next?

For the person with the folder, the answer is usually no. They don't have an information problem. They have an interpretation and application problem.

Those are people problems.

What AI does well

I'm not anti-AI. We use AI tools in our own practice, and your patients use them constantly. Many arrive having already asked a chatbot what their labs mean.

AI can explain what a marker is. It can summarize a study. It can draft a reasonable list of next steps. That has real value, and it's improving fast.

What it can't do is sit across from a person and notice what isn't being said.

What people see that data can't

Interpreting data for a human being is different from interpreting data. A number tells you what is happening. A person helps you understand why it keeps happening.

A few patterns I've watched on repeat for decades:

The sleep score that won't improve. The tracker says poor sleep, night after night. A conversation reveals she answers email at 11 p.m. because it's the only quiet hour in her house. No supplement fixes that. A discussion on work, priorities and a forgiving plan with accountability does.

The client who agrees to everything. He nods through every recommendation in the room and does none of them at home. That usually isn't a discipline problem. It's a plan built for someone with a different life who has been taught not to ask questions in your office.

The person who needs one change, not five. Knowing which change comes first, and when to add the second, is judgment you only build by watching people over time.

"I'm fine." Hearing it, and knowing it isn't true.

None of these is one specific client. Each is a pattern, and each one is invisible in the folder.

Motivation rises and falls. Stress hides inside schedules. Embarrassment keeps people from reporting the week that went sideways. A good coach reads those signals and adjusts, and that's often where progress is won or lost.

Collaboration multiplies it

One person can't hold all of it either. Our team includes an exercise physiologist, a functional nutritionist, and a mental fitness/mindfulness coach. Each stays in their lane, and we compare notes.

That's where patterns surface. A nutritionist might notice a client skipping lunch on long workdays while the exercise physiologist notices that same client's afternoon sessions falling apart. Neither observation tells the whole story alone. Together, they point to one practical fix.

The physician belongs at the center of that circle. Diagnosis and recommendations belong with you. Our job is to help your patients act on them between visits, and to report back so you can see what's working.

When the next test can wait

When the next result is unlikely to change what a patient does, the most helpful referral may not be to another lab. It may be to people who can help them understand what they already have and live it.

When we do test again, it's on purpose, against a plan the person has been following. That's when the numbers mean something, because someone is there to read them alongside the person they belong to.

Thirty years later

When I started, a client's data was a pulse taken by hand and a step counter clipped to their hip. Today the information available is extraordinary, and I'm grateful for it.

But the part that changes lives hasn't moved. It's still people helping people: someone who knows your history, notices the patterns, tells you the truth kindly, and stays with you long enough for the plan to work.

More data can show us where someone stands. People help them get somewhere new.

If you'd like to compare notes on the patients in your practice who have plenty of information and not enough traction, I'd welcome the conversation. Message me here, or see how we work at eightyeighteleven.com.

Previous
Previous

Our Mental Fitness Coach, the credential behind the role, and what the discipline covers.

Next
Next

A patient comes in with eleven supplements and no plan. What do you do first, and why that rather than cutting them all?